Size comparison at the same scale
- Easy
- Intermediate
- Difficult
- Ski route
- Lift
Every panel is drawn at the same scale, north at the top, from the routing graph the SkiAllDay app navigates on. Piste colours follow each resort's own grading. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Key facts
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte goes higher, to 1,860 m against 813 m at Winterberg, and has the bigger vertical drop: 1,120 m against 211 m at Winterberg. Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte is the steeper on average, with a mean piste gradient of 16% against 12% at Winterberg. A skier who stays on easy runs can reach 59% of the piste at Winterberg from the base, against 58% at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte. An adult day pass costs less at Winterberg: EUR 52 against EUR 66 at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte.
| Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte | Winterberg | |
|---|---|---|
| Pistesthe operator's figure | 42 km | 27.5 km |
| Pistes, measuredalong the routing graph | 34.8 km | 18.3 km |
| Vertical drop | 1,120 m | 211 m |
| Highest lift | 1,860 m | 813 m |
| Lowest piste | 740 m | 602 m |
| Lifts | 14 | 25 |
| Adult day passmain season | EUR 66 | EUR 52 |
| Winter season | December – March | December – March |
Piste length, lift count, altitudes and prices are the operators' published figures as each guide cites them. The measured piste length is this site's own, taken along the centre line of every piste in the routing graph, which is why it runs shorter than a marketed total.
Terrain
Difficulty split
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte
- Easy48%20 km
- Intermediate48%20 km
- Difficult5%2 km
Winterberg
- Easy51%14 km
- Intermediate44%12 km
- Difficult5%1.5 km
Each resort grades its own pistes, so a red in one country can be a blue in another. The gradient table below is measured the same way everywhere.
Gradient, measured
| Gradient | Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte | Winterberg |
|---|---|---|
| 0–10% | ||
| 10–20% | ||
| 20–30% | ||
| 30–40% | ||
| 40%+ |
Share of ski terrain in each gradient band, measured along the run, with marked ski routes counted beside the pistes. A 30% gradient is about 17 degrees.
Terrain by altitude
| Altitude | Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte | Winterberg |
|---|---|---|
| 1,600–2,000 m | ||
| 1,200–1,600 m | ||
| 800–1,200 m | ||
| 400–800 m |
Kilometres of ski terrain in each 400 m band, pistes and marked ski routes together, on one scale. The bars show how high each ski area sits and how much of it is up there.
Aspect
The direction each run descends towards, weighted by length; the outer ring is 40%. North-facing slopes hold snow longest and south-facing ones soften first in spring.
Measured on the network
These come from walking each resort's lift and piste network in the SkiAllDay routing graph, the same way for every ski area, so the columns compare directly. No resort publishes most of them.
| Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte | Winterberg | |
|---|---|---|
| Longest continuous descentlinked pistes, no lift in between | 6.8 km | 1.6 km |
| Vertical on that descent | 696 m | 178 m |
| Reachable on easy runs onlyshare of piste, from the base | 58% | 59% |
| Mean piste gradientweighted by length | 16% | 12% |
| North-facing terrainN, NE and NW | 73% | 50% |
| Median piste altitudehalf the piste lies above it | 1,403 m | 720 m |
| Piste above 2,500 m | 0% | 0% |
| Uphill on surface liftsshare of the climbing, by vertical | 8% | 30% |
Where a resort publishes one of these figures itself, its own number is shown and marked official. Each guide explains the method and carries the full set.
Skier by skier
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte
Goes well for
- Long, single descents: the run from the Steinplatte summit down to Seegatterl is Germany's longest, about 9 km with 1,100 m of vertical, according to schneehoehen.de
- Reliable snow low down: Reit im Winkl is nicknamed the 'Schneeloch' (snow hole), and Winklmoosalm still runs 12 km of piste on natural snow with no cannons at all
- A two-country day on one lift ticket: the German and Austrian networks meet at the Möseralm
Goes badly for
- The cheap ticket: 'Winklmoosalm' alone buys 12 of the 42 km; the black run and the long valley descent both sit on the pricier 'Steinplatte' side
- Advanced skiers: skiresort.de grades just 2 of the 42 km black, and that is a single run, the Nordhang
- Thin-snow starts: Winklmoosalm has no snowmaking of its own, so the German side and its share of the border crossing can stay shut even while Steinplatte is open
Winterberg
Goes well for
- A repeatable day or evening trip from the Ruhr conurbation: about 110 km and just over an hour by car via the A44 and A46 through Meschede, Bestwig and Olsberg, or 108 minutes direct by train on the Dortmund-Sauerland-Express from Dortmund Hauptbahnhof
- Beginners: our own measurement finds 59% of the network reachable from the base on easy runs alone, the highest share of the ten German resorts in this project (just ahead of Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte's 58%), backed by a dedicated, roughly 10,000 square metre children's ski area at Herrloh with its own conveyor lift
- Anyone who wants more hours in the day: floodlit night skiing runs every Tuesday and Friday from 18:30 to 22:00 on what the operator calls the largest floodlight system in West Germany, on a separate ticket from the daytime pass
Goes badly for
- Advanced skiers wanting real vertical: our own measurement finds the longest run that never rides a lift is 1.64 km with 178 m of vertical, by far the shortest of the ten German resorts in this project, and only 1.5 of the marketed 27.5 km is graded difficult
- Anyone assuming the whole 'Karussell' skis as one mountain: our own measurement of the network finds the Nordhang lift and the separately branded Familienskigebiet Sahnehang sit outside the connected core, reached by shuttle bus rather than by ski
- Anyone relying on natural snow: at 602 to 813 m, Winterberg sits lower than every other resort in this project, and the operator's own site describes machine-made snow on all but two of its 29 groomed runs; a mild spell without it closes most of the mountain
Rated for the same skier
| Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte | Winterberg | |
|---|---|---|
| First-timers | good First-timer. Winklmoosalm is marketed by its own operator specifically 'for families and beginners': 12 km of gentle, natural-snow piste with nothing steep to stumble into. | excellent First-timer. 14 km of the marketed 27.5 km is graded easy, and our own measurement finds 59% of the whole network reachable from the base without leaving an easy run, the highest share of the ten German resorts in this project, just ahead of Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte's 58%. The Kinderskiland at Herrloh gives young beginners about 10,000 square metres of their own terrain, with tipis and figure courses served by a conveyor belt. |
| Second-week skiers | good Second-week skier. 20 of the 42 km is blue-graded and another 20 red, so there is plenty of room to move up without leaving easy terrain far behind. | good Second-week skier. 12 km of the operator's 27.5 km is graded intermediate, at a gentle length-weighted average gradient of 12%, the lowest of the ten resorts measured here. It rewards mileage and confidence-building more than technical challenge. |
| Families | excellent Family with mixed abilities. Several pistes on both sides are flagged as family slopes on the operators' own map, and the Steinplatte side adds the Triassic Funline, a dinosaur-themed course for children between the snowpark and a family piste. | excellent Family with young children. The Kinderskiland at Herrloh, six dedicated practice and conveyor lifts spread across the area, and a network of family-run Skihütten with children's menus make this an easy first ski trip. Floodlit night skiing on Tuesdays and Fridays also suits a family driving up from the Ruhr for an evening rather than a full day. |
| Advanced and expert | poor Advanced skier. Skiresort.de grades just 2 of the 42 km black, and that is one run, the Nordhang. The 4 km of ski routes are the only other terrain with any edge to it. | poor Advanced skier. Only 1.5 km of the marketed 27.5 km is graded difficult, and our own measurement finds the longest run that never rides a lift is 1.64 km with 178 m of vertical, by far the shortest of the ten German resorts measured here. There is no equivalent of a real Alpine black run. |
| Intermediates | excellent Confident intermediate. 20 km of red piste across two connected ski areas, plus Germany's longest run, the roughly 9 km descent from the Steinplatte summit to Seegatterl. | fair Confident intermediate wanting a full day's skiing. The terrain suits this level, but the day does not stretch as far as the piste count suggests. Our own measurement finds skiers here spend 127 minutes riding lifts for every hour spent descending, more than any other resort in this project except Zugspitze, simply because the runs themselves are so short. |
Taken from each guide's verdict, where every claim is cited: Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte and Winterberg.
Tips from skiers
One tip from each part of the guides' community research, gathered from public forum threads. Every tip links the discussion it came from.
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte
-
Timing and crowds
When the Rossalmbahn chair above Seegatterl is stacked, take the parallel Rossalm drag instead of waiting.
-
Runs worth your time
After adequate fresh snow, prioritise Plattenkogel and the steep, ungroomed Nordabfahrt rather than assuming Steinplatte is only an intermediate cruising hill.
-
Food and money
Buy the cheaper Winklmoosalm-only pass when the day's real objective is teaching children or absolute beginners rather than visiting Steinplatte.
-
Getting there and parking
For a holiday start from Seegatterl, be parked before 09:00 rather than merely arriving around lift opening.
-
Mistakes people make
Do not park in Waidring expecting to ski to the valley at the end of the day, because the normal return is downhill in the gondola.
Winterberg
-
Timing and crowds
Choose a non-holiday weekday over a Saturday: a January 2013 alpinforum.com insider guide says a half midweek day covers more runs than a full peak Saturday.
-
Runs worth your time
Prioritise Kappe's black Slalomhang and red piste early; use the blue Waldschneise mainly as an easier exit or transfer.
-
Food and money
At Kappe, eat at Panorama Restaurant near the bobsleigh track rather than automatically choosing Bobhaus at the summit.
-
Getting there and parking
On a busy northern approach, do not automatically enter P6 Remmeswiese/Rauher Busch simply because it is the first obvious access point.
-
Mistakes people make
Do not interpret Winterberg's red and black labels as Alpine-length expert terrain.
Questions
Which is better, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg?
That depends on who is skiing. In the guides' ratings, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte is rated higher for intermediates; Winterberg is rated higher for first-timers; the two are rated the same for second-week skiers, families and advanced and expert skiers.
Is Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte bigger than Winterberg?
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte is the larger by the operators' figures, with 42 km of piste against 27.5 km at Winterberg. Measured along the routing graph, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte comes to 34.8 km and Winterberg to 18.3 km. On the ground, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte spans 3.4 km east to west and 7.7 km north to south and Winterberg spans 3.1 km east to west and 2.2 km north to south.
Which is higher, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg?
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte has the higher top station. Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte runs from 740 m to 1,860 m and Winterberg runs from 602 m to 813 m. Half of the piste length lies above 1,403 m at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte and 720 m at Winterberg.
Which has steeper pistes, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg?
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte, on the mean piste gradient: 16% against 12% at Winterberg. Counting ski routes with the pistes, runs steeper than 30% make up 7% of the terrain at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte and 3% at Winterberg.
Is Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg better for beginners?
From the base, a skier who never leaves easy runs can reach 58% of the piste at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte and 59% of the piste at Winterberg. For a first-timer, the guides rate Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte good and Winterberg excellent.
Which has the longer runs, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg?
The longest descent that never rides a lift is 6.8 km at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte (696 m of vertical) and 1.6 km at Winterberg (178 m of vertical).
Which has the cheaper lift pass, Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg?
An adult day pass in the main season is EUR 66 at Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte and EUR 52 at Winterberg. Winterberg is the cheaper.
Is Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte or Winterberg better for families?
The guides rate Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte excellent and Winterberg excellent for families. Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte: Several pistes on both sides are flagged as family slopes on the operators' own map, and the Steinplatte side adds the Triassic Funline, a dinosaur-themed course for children between the snowpark and a family piste. Winterberg: The Kinderskiland at Herrloh, six dedicated practice and conveyor lifts spread across the area, and a network of family-run Skihütten with children's menus make this an easy first ski trip. Floodlit night skiing on Tuesdays and Fridays also suits a family driving up from the Ruhr for an evening rather than a full day.
Full guides and other comparisons
- Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte: the full guide
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte is the ski area skiresort.com ranks as the largest in Germany by piste length, and only about half of it is actually in Germany.
- Winterberg: the full guide
Winterberg is the outlier of this project: Germany's biggest ski area outside the Alps, spread across low hills at 602 to 813 m, about two hours from the Ruhr conurbation by car.
Winklmoosalm-Steinplatte compared with
SkiWelt Wilder Kaiser - Brixental · Skicircus Saalbach Hinterglemm Leogang Fieberbrunn · KitzSki (Kitzbühel / Kirchberg) · Stöten · Sälen: Lindvallen & Högfjället · Balderschwang · Idre Fjäll · Garmisch-Classic · Fellhorn/Kanzelwand · Oberjoch · Sudelfeld · Zugspitze