Size comparison at the same scale
- Easy
- Intermediate
- Difficult
- Ski route
- Lift
Every panel is drawn at the same scale, north at the top, from the routing graph the SkiAllDay app navigates on. Piste colours follow each resort's own grading. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Key facts
Andermatt–Sedrun goes higher, to 2,961 m against 2,883 m at Crans-Montana, and has the bigger vertical drop: 1,517 m against 1,372 m at Crans-Montana. Andermatt–Sedrun is the steeper on average, with a mean piste gradient of 21% against 19% at Crans-Montana. A skier who stays on easy runs can reach 45% of the piste at Andermatt–Sedrun from the base, against 10% at Crans-Montana. An adult day pass costs less at Crans-Montana: CHF 89 against CHF 99 at Andermatt–Sedrun.
| Andermatt–Sedrun | Crans-Montana | |
|---|---|---|
| Pistesthe operator's figure | 120 km | 140 km |
| Pistes, measuredalong the routing graph | 62.7 km | 72.2 km |
| Vertical drop | 1,517 m | 1,372 m |
| Highest lift | 2,961 m | 2,883 m |
| Lowest piste | 1,444 m | 1,511 m |
| Lifts | 22 | 24 |
| Adult day passmain season | CHF 99 | CHF 89 |
| Winter season | November – April | November – April |
Piste length, lift count, altitudes and prices are the operators' published figures as each guide cites them. The measured piste length is this site's own, taken along the centre line of every piste in the routing graph, which is why it runs shorter than a marketed total.
Terrain
Difficulty split
Andermatt–Sedrun
- Easy30%36 km
- Intermediate50%60 km
- Difficult20%24 km
Crans-Montana
- Easy39%55 km
- Intermediate50%70 km
- Difficult11%15 km
Each resort grades its own pistes, so a red in one country can be a blue in another. The gradient table below is measured the same way everywhere.
Gradient, measured
| Gradient | Andermatt–Sedrun | Crans-Montana |
|---|---|---|
| 0–10% | ||
| 10–20% | ||
| 20–30% | ||
| 30–40% | ||
| 40%+ |
Share of ski terrain in each gradient band, measured along the run, with marked ski routes counted beside the pistes. A 30% gradient is about 17 degrees.
Terrain by altitude
| Altitude | Andermatt–Sedrun | Crans-Montana |
|---|---|---|
| 2,800–3,200 m | ||
| 2,400–2,800 m | ||
| 2,000–2,400 m | ||
| 1,600–2,000 m | ||
| 1,200–1,600 m |
Kilometres of ski terrain in each 400 m band, pistes and marked ski routes together, on one scale. The bars show how high each ski area sits and how much of it is up there.
Aspect
The direction each run descends towards, weighted by length; the outer ring is 30%. North-facing slopes hold snow longest and south-facing ones soften first in spring.
Measured on the network
These come from walking each resort's lift and piste network in the SkiAllDay routing graph, the same way for every ski area, so the columns compare directly. No resort publishes most of them.
| Andermatt–Sedrun | Crans-Montana | |
|---|---|---|
| Longest continuous descentlinked pistes, no lift in between | 11.9 km | 8.3 km |
| Vertical on that descent | 1,557 m | 1,361 m |
| Reachable on easy runs onlyshare of piste, from the base | 45% | 10% |
| Mean piste gradientweighted by length | 21% | 19% |
| North-facing terrainN, NE and NW | 37% | 4% |
| Median piste altitudehalf the piste lies above it | 2,112 m | 1,977 m |
| Piste above 2,500 m | 13% | 2% |
| Uphill on surface liftsshare of the climbing, by vertical | 12% | 16% |
Where a resort publishes one of these figures itself, its own number is shown and marked official. Each guide explains the method and carries the full set.
Skier by skier
Andermatt–Sedrun
Goes well for
- Confident intermediates and freeriders drawn to Gemsstock's long, north-facing red and black terrain
- Skiers on the Epic Pass, since Vail Resorts operates the lift company
- Travellers without a car: Andermatt sits on the Matterhorn Gotthard Bahn
Goes badly for
- Absolute beginners: most terrain sits above the treeline and the resort's nursery slopes are small and split from the main lift network
- Anyone wanting Disentis in the same day without a long linkup: it takes a cable car or train, not a piste, to get there
- Skiers chasing the marketed 180 km figure on piste alone: our own measurement of the two piste-linked sectors is well under half that
Crans-Montana
Goes well for
- Intermediates who want wide, sunny, south-facing cruisers rather than steep terrain
- Families, with dedicated nursery areas at Snow Island (on the golf course) and Snow Garden at Arnouva
- Epic Pass holders looking for a European stop without blackout dates
Goes badly for
- Skiers based in Aminona itself: the village lost its uplift in 2014 and still has none
- Anyone chasing north-facing, shaded snow: our own measurement finds only 4% of the piste network faces north
- Expert piste skiers: marked black terrain is a modest share of the network outside race season on the Piste Nationale
Rated for the same skier
| Andermatt–Sedrun | Crans-Montana | |
|---|---|---|
| First-timers | poor First-timer. Terrain is mostly above the treeline and the one small nursery area is not linked to the main network. | excellent First-timer. Two purpose-built nursery areas with magic carpets, at the golf course in town and at Arnouva. |
| Families | fair The Valtgeva kids' area sits apart from the main lift network, and much of the terrain is high and exposed. | excellent Dedicated children's areas, gentle terrain low on the mountain, and a plateau setting with little elevation to manage. |
| Advanced and expert | excellent Strong intermediate / advanced. Gemsstock's north-facing pistes and the Bernhard-Russi Run give real vertical and consistently colder snow. | fair Expert on-piste. Black terrain is a modest share of the marked network outside the Piste Nationale race course. |
| Intermediates | good Improving intermediate. Wide cruising on the Nätschen–Oberalp side; Gemsstock's reds run longer and steeper than elsewhere. | excellent Intermediate. Wide, sunny, south-facing red cruising is what the resort is built around. |
| Non-skiers | good Andermatt village, the Schöllenen Gorge railway and the Gotthard Pass history are all reachable without skis. | fair The Plaine Morte glacier viewpoint and cross-country tracks are reachable by lift, but there is no single landmark comparable to Zermatt's Matterhorn. |
Taken from each guide's verdict, where every claim is cited: Andermatt–Sedrun and Crans-Montana.
Tips from skiers
One tip from each part of the guides' community research, gathered from public forum threads. Every tip links the discussion it came from.
Andermatt–Sedrun
-
Timing and crowds
For a powder or limited-opening weekend at Gemsstock, aim for the base around 07:30 rather than 08:00, because the first section sometimes loads before its nominal 08:30 start and an 08:00 arrival has already meant waiting several cabins.
-
Runs worth your time
On a cold clear midwinter day, use south-facing Nätschen–Oberalp for sunshine and save north-facing Gemsstock for preserved snow.
-
Food and money
If skiing two or more separate days, price the resort's CHF 69 half-price pass before buying ordinary day tickets.
-
Getting there and parking
A low-friction car-free setup is to stay in Göschenen, commute by train and leave skis and boots in the Gleis 0 lockers at Andermatt station.
-
Mistakes people make
Do not treat Andermatt–Disentis as a casual out-and-back, because one-way travel has taken about four hours even without lift queues.
Crans-Montana
-
Timing and crowds
For the earliest start, use Montana–Arnouva when its published opening is earlier than Violettes Express.
-
Runs worth your time
Prioritise Nationale and Chetseron rather than repeatedly skiing the flatter, busier descent into Montana.
-
Food and money
Choose the Cry d'Er café and terrace pizza over Arnouva when queues and value matter.
-
Getting there and parking
From Sierre, take the funicular to Montana and the free local ski bus rather than driving into the plateau's parking congestion.
-
Mistakes people make
Do not descend to Aminona expecting a gondola or chair to bring you back into the ski area.
Questions
Which is better, Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana?
That depends on who is skiing. In the guides' ratings, Andermatt–Sedrun is rated higher for advanced and expert skiers and non-skiers; Crans-Montana is rated higher for first-timers, families and intermediates.
Is Andermatt–Sedrun bigger than Crans-Montana?
Crans-Montana is the larger by the operators' figures, with 140 km of piste against 120 km at Andermatt–Sedrun. Measured along the routing graph, Andermatt–Sedrun comes to 62.7 km and Crans-Montana to 72.2 km. On the ground, Andermatt–Sedrun spans 16.8 km east to west and 12.6 km north to south and Crans-Montana spans 6.3 km east to west and 6.9 km north to south.
Which is higher, Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana?
Andermatt–Sedrun has the higher top station. Andermatt–Sedrun runs from 1,444 m to 2,961 m and Crans-Montana runs from 1,511 m to 2,883 m. Half of the piste length lies above 2,112 m at Andermatt–Sedrun and 1,977 m at Crans-Montana.
Which has steeper pistes, Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana?
Andermatt–Sedrun, on the mean piste gradient: 21% against 19% at Crans-Montana. Counting ski routes with the pistes, runs steeper than 30% make up 24% of the terrain at Andermatt–Sedrun and 12% at Crans-Montana.
Is Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana better for beginners?
From the base, a skier who never leaves easy runs can reach 45% of the piste at Andermatt–Sedrun and 10% of the piste at Crans-Montana. For a first-timer, the guides rate Andermatt–Sedrun poor and Crans-Montana excellent.
Which has the longer runs, Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana?
The longest descent that never rides a lift is 11.9 km at Andermatt–Sedrun (1,557 m of vertical) and 8.3 km at Crans-Montana (1,361 m of vertical).
Which has the cheaper lift pass, Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana?
An adult day pass in the main season is CHF 99 at Andermatt–Sedrun and CHF 89 at Crans-Montana. Crans-Montana is the cheaper.
Is Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana better for families?
The guides rate Andermatt–Sedrun fair and Crans-Montana excellent for families. Andermatt–Sedrun: The Valtgeva kids' area sits apart from the main lift network, and much of the terrain is high and exposed. Crans-Montana: Dedicated children's areas, gentle terrain low on the mountain, and a plateau setting with little elevation to manage.
Is Andermatt–Sedrun or Crans-Montana better for non-skiers?
The guides rate Andermatt–Sedrun good and Crans-Montana fair for non-skiers. Andermatt–Sedrun: Andermatt village, the Schöllenen Gorge railway and the Gotthard Pass history are all reachable without skis. Crans-Montana: The Plaine Morte glacier viewpoint and cross-country tracks are reachable by lift, but there is no single landmark comparable to Zermatt's Matterhorn.
Full guides and other comparisons
- Andermatt–Sedrun: the full guide
Andermatt–Sedrun is a Vail Resorts-operated Swiss ski area that links Andermatt's Nätschen and Oberalp slopes to Sedrun over the Oberalp Pass, plus the separate Gemsstock massif reached by its own cable car straight from…
- Crans-Montana: the full guide
Crans-Montana is a sunny, south-facing Valais resort spread across the plateau villages of Crans, Montana and Barzettes, with lifts running from about 1,500 m up to 2,883 m below the Plaine Morte glacier.
Andermatt–Sedrun compared with
Zermatt · 4 Vallées (Verbier) · LAAX · Grindelwald–Wengen · St. Moritz – Corviglia · Silvretta Montafon · Kronplatz · Hochkönig · Snow Space Salzburg · Obersaxen Mundaun · Meiringen-Hasliberg
Crans-Montana compared with
4 Vallées (Verbier) · Zermatt · Sölden · Mayrhofen · Silvretta Montafon · Kronplatz · Grimentz-Zinal · Gstaad – Saanenmöser, Schönried & Zweisimmen · Adelboden-Lenk · St-Luc/Chandolin